Was Einstein a fake and a plagiarist?
Was Einstein a fake and a plagiarist?. Are You mam & sir has that kind of problem?, If yes then please read the best tips right after below:
Questions of this kind have an interesting history. The first person to strongly push the view that Einstein was a fake and plagiarist was a Nobel Prize winner, Philipp Lenard. He won the Prize in 1905 for his experimental work on cathode rays. Here he is:
Initially, Einstein and Lenard got on well, and their correspondence involved statements of mutual admiration. But this soured during the First World War, during which Lenard got more and more involved in German nationalism.
Lenard became convinced of two things: first that there was a distinct type of “Deutsche Physik” that was experimentally based, and was the only “right” way to do science. This was in contrast to the theoretically-led science exemplified by Einstein’s relativity as well as the new quantum theory that was being created at the time. This, he started dismissing as “Jewish Physics”. Second, Lenard started to believe deeply in anti-semitism more generally, and in particular in the pernicious influence of the “Jewish international press” that he believed were unfairly publicising and promoting Einstein’s theories.
In 1920 Lenard attacked Einstein openly at a research conference with personal insults based on his heritage. As he put it: a “Jewish spirit” had come to rule over physics. Science, “like everything else man produces” was down to bloodlines, and the Jewish Einstein, though German, was central to this problem. As Lenard put it at this conference: “Just because a goat is born in a stable does not make him a noble thoroughbred.”
In this conference Lenard went on to accuse Einstein both of being a fake (i.e., that his arguments were self-contradictory and made no sense) and of being a plagiarist (Lenard published a series of papers which artificially assigned various principles and some of the experimental consequences of special relativity to an assortment of obscure 19th century German scientists). In 1933 Lenard collected these thoughts and views into a large textbook “Great Men in Science”, which omitted all mention of Einstein (as well as of Röntgen and Marie Curie with whom he had also had fights). This book was still being read after the Second World War.
Naturally, Lenard’s views made him a great favourite of the rising Nazi party, and he became “Chief of Aryan Physics” under the Nazi regime. He was also a scientific adviser to Adolf Hitler, where his suspicion of theoretical “Jewish physics” may well have contributed to the lack of Nazi interest in pursuing the concept of an atomic weapon. By the end of the war, he was 82 years old and so escaped prosecution, but instead retired to a small German village and died in 1947.
When Einstein is accused of fakery or plagiarism, people often explicitly refer back to Lenard’s papers, his criticisms and his rewritings of history. It is not entirely clear whether they realise that they are rehashing Nazi propaganda in doing so.
As for other people who were working on issues connected to relativity at the time: Lorentz, Poincare and Minkowski, they themselves are on record as assigning the principal credit to Einstein. Of his contemporaries, it is only Philipp Lenard and his Nazi party colleagues who allege fakery or plagiarism.
My apologies, that was a bit of a detour. With all that in mind: what kind of fakery and plagiarism did you have in mind, Anonymous question-asker?
We at this situspanda dotcom hope if those solutions listed above can solve your problem. Thanks